How is the 8th grade sheet harder than the 7th grade one?

The sentences are longer and the easy signals are gone. Counterclaims read like plain facts, some with numbers, and rebuttals open by admitting the other side has a point before answering it. Students have to follow the whole sentence to see where it lands.

What should my student do if a sentence seems to fit two labels?

Ask whose side the sentence ends on. Evidence never mentions the other side, a counterclaim never answers it, and a rebuttal always does both. Every sentence on the sheet fits exactly one of those.

Is this practice for reading or for writing?

Both. Spotting these parts in someone else's argument is the reading skill, and building an essay from them is the writing skill. The best follow-up is to have your student write a rebuttal for one of the counterclaims.

8th grade claim and counterclaim

8th grade claim and counterclaim worksheets

Eighth graders sort the same four jobs in longer, less obvious sentences. Counterclaims show up as plain facts with no "some people say" in front, rebuttals open by granting the other side's point, and irrelevant sentences use the claim's own words while saying nothing that bears on it. Students write the job each sentence does.

Free printable PDF worksheet, aligned to Common Core W.8.1.a, RI.8.8.

Each print is a different sheet with its own answer key. You don't need to sign up.

The kind of sentences you'll fix

Read the claim and the sentence. Write the sentence's job: evidence, counterclaim, rebuttal, or irrelevant.

Claim: The school should put solar panels on the gym roof. “The gym roof is twenty-two years old and may need replacing long before the panels wear out.” The sentence is: (counterclaim / evidence / irrelevant / rebuttal).
Fixed: Claim: The school should put solar panels on the gym roof. “The gym roof is twenty-two years old and may need replacing long before the panels wear out.” The sentence is: counterclaim.
Claim: Our town should restore the old train station instead of tearing it down. “The station is one of four buildings in the county designed by the architect who planned the courthouse.” The sentence is: (counterclaim / evidence / irrelevant / rebuttal).
Claim: Middle schools should replace letter grades with written feedback. “In a pilot at two district schools, students who got written comments instead of letter grades revised their essays twice as often.” The sentence is: (counterclaim / evidence / irrelevant / rebuttal).

Every print pulls a new set of sentences at this level, so a make-up test or a second sibling gets a different mix.

What's on an 8th grade sheet

8th grade sheets draw from 52 sentences, 7 to a page. None of these sentences are on 7th grade sheets. 7th grade sheets print 8 to a page.

A few of the sentences:

Repairing the station’s roof and wiring would cost more than building a new community center from scratch.
The grocery store on Elm Street stays open until ten on weeknights.
Students headed for science careers have little room left in their schedules for a year of art.

Fix it. Read the claim and the sentence. Write the sentence's job: evidence, counterclaim, rebuttal, or irrelevant. 7 sentences to fix per page.

Every version prints on US Letter or A4, with its answer key on the last page.

How to teach this

The side question still does the work, but the sentences no longer announce themselves. Have students cover everything after the first comma or semicolon and ask what the sentence would be if it stopped there, then uncover the rest. A sentence that turns from a cost to an answer is a rebuttal. For irrelevant sentences, ask whether the fact would change a vote on the claim. A gym named after a coach shares a noun with a solar panel claim and still changes nothing. Once the labels come easily, have students write their own rebuttal for one of the sheet's counterclaims.

Watch for: A sentence with a number in it is not automatically evidence. A number can argue against the claim just as easily, and then the sentence is a counterclaim. A counterclaim is not a mistake in the essay. Good arguments bring up the other side on purpose, so they can answer it in the rebuttal. A sentence can be true and still be irrelevant. Ask whether it would change anyone's mind about the claim. If it would not, it does no work in the argument.

Common questions about 8th grade claim and counterclaim

How is the 8th grade sheet harder than the 7th grade one?: The sentences are longer and the easy signals are gone. Counterclaims read like plain facts, some with numbers, and rebuttals open by admitting the other side has a point before answering it. Students have to follow the whole sentence to see where it lands.
What should my student do if a sentence seems to fit two labels?: Ask whose side the sentence ends on. Evidence never mentions the other side, a counterclaim never answers it, and a rebuttal always does both. Every sentence on the sheet fits exactly one of those.
Is this practice for reading or for writing?: Both. Spotting these parts in someone else's argument is the reading skill, and building an essay from them is the writing skill. The best follow-up is to have your student write a rebuttal for one of the counterclaims.

Related worksheets

Ready to print one?

Need a fresh set of sentences? Download another copy.

Aligned to Common Core W.8.1.a, RI.8.8. Reviewed by the One more sheet team. Content version 241, updated September 2026.

Spot a mistake on this sheet? Tell us. · About these worksheets